why does sony require formatting to go between pal and ntsc?
the grammar being wrong also bothers me
the grammar being wrong also bothers me
Sorry, but everything you wrote there is utter bullshit as is applicable to a modern and completely digital mirrorless camera.
Are you suggesting that digital cameras don’t run on electricity? Lol
No, I’m stating the incontrovertible fact that a digital and completely DC powered device does not have the frequency of its internal components “conditioned” by its connected power source, lol.
Among quite a few other things.
Just checked this camera manual (2015 Sony Alpha 7RII). It does H.264 (it calls it AVC, and it also uses specifically AVCHD, exclusive to Sony. So, old version) encoding of video. That encoding does have PAL and NTSC hard requirements when recording 24fps, 1080 24fps is only possible in progressive mode, which means it is tied to analog standards. The rolling shutter has to match the target frame rate. Encoding is done on the memory card, it is called real time compression. It is a format intended to create DVD and Blu-Ray direct compatibility files. Which were still, back then, held back by PAL and NTSC standards as they were targeting a TV market that were still technically very analog limited¹.
The camera also has TV out (early microHDMI it seems), which is also limited by PAL/NTSC compatibility of the TV.
Like, this camera won’t do 24fps video in PAL mode, for example. It also won’t do MP4 for more than 20 minutes because it has a file size limit of 4GB. That is the age of technology we are dealing with. Things are not magical just because they are digital. There are hard technical limits and there’s a history behind the development of technology we have today. This camera cannot record certain fps settings when an HDMI monitor is connected at the same time, that tells me there’s hard wired video processing that lock steps a ton of what the camera can and cannot do.
¹: quick note, TVs are actually still limited by NTSC/PAL standards. Manufacturers have just implemented several tricks to circumvent technical limitations. Such as TVs nowadays can detect which type of grid they are connected to and pick and choose workarounds depending on what the user is trying to play. This usually creates certain artifacts, like when a 50hz TV is trying to play a 24fps or 60fps digital video, for example. For the vast majority of content you wouldn’t notice unless you were looking for it. But on some movies it is extremely obvious, since it changes the pace of movement by dropping or repeating frames in a way that was not intended by the file format.
You are just making completely wild guesses here.
Seriously you sound like a LLM stuck in a hallucination.
I know it is fashionable to be mad at people online, and call bullshit and throw insults like little children on a playground, but several things:
This is a video limitation, not shutter speed for still pictures. When you go from a physical shutter to a rolling shutter, the transistors on the CMOS sensor have to be coupled to a specific clock, at which rate they can flush voltage to the video processor. That clock conditions everything, and this specific camera obviously has some clock lock step somewhere in the video processing chain that affect writes to disk because it’s specifications state very clearly a ton of limitations that cannot be explained away by legal bickering. (Not even to mention the other complexities like ISO amplification and a myriad of other factors also altering the rolling shutter refresh rate.)
So, from the manual:




My suspicion is that it has to do with using an ancient HDMI (and ancient codecs, because WTF is limiting MP4 to 4GB) and also the ties, at the time, of Blu-ray digital file formats compatibility with TVs. Back then, H.264 was still very NTSC/PAL oriented. That was the tail end of interlaced and progressive frame compression.
I’m completely confident that you are all super duper more intelligenter than Sony engineers. But again, just because it is digital, and just because it is Sony, and just because it was an expensive flagship, doesn’t mean it is magical. There’s a history and a cost in engineering R&D time for making these digital features we take for granted today, that did not exist 11 years ago.
As for: “TVs now don’t get sync from the mains.” That is true, but did you know that LEDs still refresh their voltage state at a regular interval that is fixed at manufacturing time? Which interval to use will depend on which market the TV is intended for. And, for convenience sake, factories still use NTSC or PAL as standard. This is why TVs are either 50hz or 60hz or 100hz or 120hz, even if they are LED or based on other solid state components. Your attitude is like somehow engineers nullified basic physics, no, they didn’t. They found workarounds so end users don’t have to think about it as much. But the technical constraints are still there. A 50hz TV will show an entirely different viewing experience of a 24fps movie, than a 60hz TV. Even if both are technically using the exact same LED technology, and both are internally DC electricity that is technically independent of the mains frequency.
I’m not mad at you, I’m just stating you are rambling on about things that makes no sense. Hense the LLM comment I made. I genuinely feel like I’m interacting with an LLM here.
I’m also not saying I’m smarter than the software engineers that worked on this product. You seem to assume that I think I am.
You also assume I have an attitude that physics don’t matter.
You keep talking about mains frequency and TVs which is not related to the topic of formatting a SD card to change from NTSC to PAL. The camera makes its own clock internally arbitrarily FACT. Otherwise, you’d be locked into a single multiple of 1/50 or 1/60 a second as I mentioned in another comment.
You keep adding side notes “did you know…?” that 1, don’t make any sense, and 2 aren’t even remotely about this original topic.
You are the one who gives me the impression “I don’t read the other posters comments” and can’t stop and think “hey, maybe I’m wrong here”, but rather you think you need to belittle me and say “I’m completely confident that you are all super duper more intelligenter than Sony engineers.”
I’m giving my impressions as I understand them. You are free to disagree, but come at me with technical reasons. Attack the argument, not the person. All I’ve read is “you don’t know what you are talking about, this is bullshit, you are an LLM”.
None of that disproves my points. Sorry if faced with nothing but ad-hominens I don’t take your comments seriously. You’d understand my frustration.
The camera makes its own clock internally arbitrarily FACT.
FALSE, the camera has a set clock, whichever the image processor runs at. It can’t make up new clocks arbitrarily. It has to use technical workarounds to provide a wider range of options for the user, and this creates technical limitations. The physical shutter CAN run at arbitrary shutter speeds, BECAUSE it is mechanical. The rolling shutter CANNOT run at arbitrary shutter speeds, because it is locked to the processor, and whatever the sensor can or cannot do.
The camera doesn’t set the file format arbitrarily because back then the encoding format couldn’t do it, FACT.
If you can’t seem to link why I’m talking about this things with OPs question and don’t seem to be able to come with a logical counter argument, have you considered that, hey, maybe you are wrong here?
Alright, I will admit after reading for a while about how the electronic curtain works on cameras, I was wrong about the clock of the sensor being variable. I assumed the line to line timing was variable, but I was wrong there.
BUT the main dispute I have here with our engagement is the weird justification you mentioned for requiring FORMATTING an SD card.
I can understand a reboot for this, but a format? That doesn’t make any sense. I don’t even think I need to reboot my cameras to switch from NTSC to PAL, nevermind a format.
I was speculating, we are all here together trying to answer OP’s question. As far as I remember, interlacing H.264 used to lead to weird really long processing times. Encoding took a long while as a tradeoff for way faster decoding. Which resulted on the speed of data writes being violently throttled when image processing took too long, not a problem when encoding disk to disk, like burning a video into Blu-Ray for example. But it was a problem when recording from a camera, which risked running out of working memory while frames were still coming in hot from the CMOS. So, engineers resorted to compressing on the storage rather than on RAM, as to free up processing resources, this was called real-time compressing (I know it is a counter intuitive name but software devs aren’t the best at naming things). They wrote pre-compression data directly to storage first, this freed up resources on the processor and RAM side so frames weren’t dropped. Then later, the video would be slowly compressed and the result written, again, in-situ on the final file format. In exchange, this process locked the video processing to the formatting of the physical storage media (stuff like format, block size, addresses and caches).
I have no basis to affirm whether this is the case on this specific camera. Maybe it is or maybe it isn’t. My best guess is that, either way, Sony engineers just said “fuck it, force the user to reformat, no one is ever gonna change that one setting other than the first time they use the camera”, and just moved on.
Certainly more modern cameras, with faster processors, better compression algorithms like HEVC, variable rolling shutter speeds with anti-flicker (even global shutters which are all the rage now) and free from the archaic compatibility issues of NTSC/PAL video signal processors, this is no longer a problem.
Please explain, I’m interested in the technical details.
What this commenter wrote almost makes sense if this camera were an oldschool analog device, think the era of tape camcorders and VCRs and so forth. And tube televisions and even the retro game consoles connected to them, for that matter. These machines were all heavily tied to the frequency and timings of their native video signal format, either NTSC or PAL (or even SECAM, if you want to get really obscure).
This is absolutely not the case with a modern flagship mirrorless camera. The Sony ɑ7RII in OP’s picture is a flagship high end camera. It is obviously not only eminently capable of altering its shutter rate, sensor refresh speed, and video recording frame rate to any arbitrary value but is purpose built to be able to do so. The only part of its componentry at all that is operating at NTSC/PAL frequencies at any point is whatever tiny amount of DAC hardware it’s using to output that low-def TV signal (probably composite video) out the little barrel jack on the side, and even then only when you’ve got it plugged into an analog TV.
Analog NTSC and PAL are very different from each other. Digital “NTSC” and “PAL” (in reality there’s really no such thing) are not. The block of NTSC countries have TV’s that expect a 60hz frame rate and those in traditionally PAL countries expect a 50hz frame rate. That’s literally it.
The following claims are bogus:
You can fake the video with just the framerate
No, that’s literally what digital HD video does nowadays, like the type you’d transmit over an HDMI cable.
implies the entire electric circuit ran at a specific frequency
This was true for analog devices and those whose timings had to be tied to the output frequency, but is not the case for a digital device that handles all of its signal processing internally.
Which is easier to do if everything inside the camera, shutter, pixel refresh, encoding, etc. runs on the same frequency.
This is not even remotely what a high end modern camera does. Sony is obviously mum about the exact specifications of the “Bionz X” main image processor in the ɑ7RII, but it is obviously a modern highly specialized chip running most likely running at many hundreds of megahertz, completely independent of the camera’s external video output.
If the camera can be fed with direct power it will also condition the internal components frequency.
I think this grammatically malformed statement is trying to imply that the camera must run in lockstep with its input power frequency. If so, this could only be true if the camera were an analog running directly off of mains current from a wall outlet. This is not so for any digital camera; they’re DC devices primarily fed from their battery which obviously has no electricity frequency and if they’re externally powered this is also through DC from an ADC to DC step down converter. No part of the mains voltage frequency should be making it to the camera. If it did, this would be very bad. Smoke would certainly be involved.
Furthermore, the mains voltage frequency is not nearly accurate or consistent enough to tie the operating frequency of any electronic device to it. You can easily observe this with oldschool analog clocks which derive their drive speed directly from the 50 or 60hz frequency of their mains power supply; they don’t keep very good time. So electronic devices even if they ostensibly “run at” their countries’ analog TV frequency at 60 or 59.94 or 50hz or whatever still use their own internal crystal oscillators to create that frequency accurately rather than blithely relying on the mains frequency.
If it is for sync when recording screens or using old lights, the entire camera must run on the same frequency, or the skip when faking framerates is actually still noticeable.
Once again it is trivially verifiable that this is not so; I have point and shoot cameras from the early 2000s which can change both their flash sync and screen sync settings on the fly with no ill effect, no reboot or reformat required, and the results are clearly visible. Anybody with a camera in their hands could verify this in about four seconds without having to resort to spouting any bullshit.
All this would require restarting the electronics to run on the correct frequency.
No, it just requires setting the recording framerate to the correct value and optionally tuning to start the frame exposure at the correct time. Which again, any competent digital camera can already do.
All this would require restarting the electronics to run on the correct frequency.
Again again, again. For the umpteenth time, the camera’s internal hardware is processing at its own internal clock speed completely independent of its video outputs.
The old encodes go beyond just containers, they do bitwise manipulation as well. Electrical system agnosticism is a modern result of newer container formats.
This is either willfully or ignorantly conflating the way that analog and digital video encoding work, with a sprinkling of buzzwords thrown in food good measure.
I will have to agree with this comment about BS.
The camera can make its own clock internally to shoot whatever frame rate it needs. Otherwise you’d be stuck at multiple of 50 or 60 Hertz for all images. You can basically arbitrarily pick a shutter speed for photos. Including 1/60 or 1/50 or 1/48 of a second. Yes I know NTSC is not 1/60, but B&W pre NTSC video was indeed 1/60 of a second sync.
Considering there are thousands of other models of cameras that let you pick PAL or NTSC without formatting, the other comment is just nonsense.
There is really no need for formatting for going from PAL to NTSC besides maybe some legal thing about how the camera is classified. Long ago there was time limits on a stills camera video recording in certain countries, not a size limit.
And that last part is really the kicker. If Sony needs to reboot the thing to get the processors running in sync or whatever it takes that’s their own prerogative. Maybe there’s a technical limitation there; I didn’t engineer the damn thing, whatever. But none of that explains why a memory card reformat should even be remotely necessary.
I’m not sure about the camera itself. But PAL and NTSC go beyond just a framerate. You can fake the video with just the framerate but it actually implies the entire electric circuit ran at a specific frequency. Which is easier to do if everything inside the camera, shutter, pixel refresh, encoding, etc. runs on the same frequency. If the camera can be fed with direct power it will also condition the internal components frequency.