It is likely advantageous to leave a route for retreat
there is one. it’s extremely dangerous as it runs through a corridor constantly barraged by mid-range ukrainian drones in kherson and zaporizhzhia, but it’s clearly there. for now.
Can’t the Russians retreat by boat?
Congrats, Ukraine!
Well done Ukraine.
“We’ll reopen it in a few hours.”
For reference, that bridge in Baltimore that was knocked out in 2024 is scheduled to reopen in the “late 2030s.” Nothing happens fast with big bridges. Especially if the massive, expensive, specialized construction barges and cranes doing the work are under threat of getting exploded like the bridge.
I don’t think the Kersk bridge will be rebuilt during the war
But comparing it to a US bridge is silly. Like saying high speed rail is infeasible because the US’ only HSR project has run absurdly over budget
The US is neither competent nor capable with those types of infrastructure projects. It doesn’t mean other countries have similar issues
Also the level of necessity is completely different
Oh, that’s not good news for the people still living in Crimea.
But, fuck 'em.
Can BBC please define the word unprecedented?
Probably because this time an entire bridge segment collapsed. Last time patching the bridge was relatively easily fixed with a cement truck. Now they’re gonna need construction barges and cranes, and it’s gonna take a long time to sort it out.
it’s entirely noncredible that the ruskies could repair this unless the war is over and they somehow get to keep crimea. they couldn’t even defend an intact bridge, they have absolutely zero chances of defending the barges that would need to float in a new arch. one stray drone there, and there will be two crimea bridges on the seafloor.
hell, it wouldn’t even sink much, the water is only about 9 meters deep there, but it would be properly ruined. it would stand there as yet another monument to russian hubris.
Where would they build the arch that is safe from Ukraine? You’d normally build it nearby and barge it into place, but it would take months to build, and Ukraine just established they can hit the area
Further, the barge becomes a very easy target that could be sunk by even a smaller drone. The sea drone that hit the bridge years ago only did minor damage, but it would easily sink a barge
Also Russia has to find a way to clear the debris from the arch. That arch was there to allow large marine traffic to transit. That channel is now blocked by the arch, and any vessels attempting to remove debris may become additional debris after a drone attack
I don’t see Russia realistically repairing this without a major change in the war
This may be Ukraines biggest win since the beginning of the war
Next the railway bridge, please.
If the repair equipment is hit with drones that will slow repairs, no?
repair in this case would have to involve building a full archway on the ground again and floating it in there with barges. it would be a turkey shoot if the ruskies ever attempted to repair this.
the real spicy thing would be if ukraine hit the cleanup crews. the rubble is currently fully cutting off the azov sea for any ships in and out, turning the bridge into a giant naval barrier that the ruskies were gracious enough to build themselves. but that only lasts until the remnants of the bridge are removed from the gap.
The road bridge is completely gone, I wonder if Ukraine hit it again, or the damage they did the first time was enough that it finally collapsed?
there’s a video from the moment of the collapse that shows an explosion at the same time. given yesterday’s tilt, i would have expected the bridge to collapse on its own anyway, but it seems ukraine didn’t wait around for that to happen.
there have also been some missile pov videos floating around that suggested they targeted the pillars of the arch, just under the road. i can’t see why the same tactic couldn’t work on the rail bridge, or how russia would suddenly be able to defend against it. ukraine didn’t trick russia on this one, they overwhelmed them.
maybe they’re waiting for nov 19 with the third strike to give donnie, putler, and pooh something to talk about
The Guardian article is worth reading as well: apparently Ukraine used a three wave attack: the first to overcome the Russian defense system, the second to act as radio repeaters so that Starlink was not needed, and the third as the actual strike force that collapsed the road bridge and damaged the rail bridge.
And all this while Trump, Putin and Xi are meeting in China.
Slava Ukraini!
A very clever attack. I almost wonder if Starlink being cutoff is why Ukraine was able to pull off this attack
If Russia had knowledge Starlink would be cutoff for a while yet (Putin and Musk have had private discussions multiple times before), Russia may have shifted defensive focus away from deeper territory like Kersk
Previously Ukraine would have been unable to launch Flamingos deep into Russia without Starlink, and standard drones were not enough to take out the bridge, as we’ve seen multiple times now
Yes. That was exactly what jumped out at me as I read the Guardian article.
We have no way of knowing, of course, but NOT relying on Starlink seems to be a very winning tactic so far. Not just because it cuts Trump and Musk out of the mix, but because Ukraine has now multiplied their drone range far beyond what anyone – including Putin – thought possible.
Whatever Trump and Musk thought they won with throttling Starlink, they’ve now lost that and more to Ukrainian ingenuity. Slava Ukraini!
Ukraine has been able to cut off Crimea for a very long time now, but chose this moment to strike.
The fact that they struck just as Putin is about to meet Xi and Trump is offcourse deeply humiliating for Putin, but the strike also going to create a huge dilemma for Russia.
Russia can’t maintain Crimea without the bridge, but Putin cannot afford the humiliating defeat of losing it either. That means Russia will have to supply Crimea through highly exposed and dangerous routes.
I’m guessing it will force Russia to divert even more resources to the south and suffer inevitable losses trying to maintain its présence in Crimea. And this comes right before winter, while Russia is still desperately trying to capture Kostiantynivka (also at staggering costs) and right as Ukraine is pushing into the vulnerable areas of the front line further to the north.
Ukraine has been able to cut off Crimea for a very long time now, but chose this moment to strike.
That’s a bold claim. Do you have sufficient evidence to back that up?
It seems extremely unlikely. Why would Ukraine sit on such a strategically important attack? They could lose the opportunity at any moment
If they could have done it when Trump was heavily pressuring Ukraine before the election, why wouldn’t they have done so? It was a much better moment for such a big victory
The rail bridge is still operational, but hopefully it puts Kiev in a better spot