However there should still be a wealth cap
“You can steal as much as you want up to a cap”
Seems like a disingenuous way of framing the issue. Providing a service/platform isn’t theft. Getting rich off it, isn’t inherently theft either.
However having the ability to facilitate theft through law by bribery is an issue, and represents an unelected power vector. That is an issue, and needs a cap.
Profiting off a service isn’t the same providing said service. Profit is all value extracted after expenses (including personal wages) of providing a service/product.
All profit is extra value charged because “fuck you, I want it”. Profit is theft.
It is not disingenuous to be in opposition to the capitalist system.
one or both sides of every transaction profit, that’s how capitalism works.
Yes and capitalism is the problem. That’s the point.
capitalism is nice, it lets me have cheap industrial machinery from failed buisness
Let’s you privatize the means of production away from the people. I.e. steal what right belongs to the community at large.
Look fuck capitalism and all that, but even in a non-capitalist system some folks will end up “wealthier” than others. They will end up profiting in ways others just can’t by having something others seek. Whether that’s from a highly sought after skill, service or platform. Like even if you drain the entire system of currency, and went back to some form of bartering and/or favor trading, some would just end up with more. Even if you tried to do it top down, black markets would form. My point being that no matter the economic structure we live under, people are greedy. Instead of trying to stomp it out, we should channel and regulate it to better ends which a wealth cap can achieve under the current systems of the world.
Would I prefer a world where that wasn’t the case? Yup. I would honestly prefer a world where socialist values were the norm. And still encourage people to create/join employee-owned businesses where possible, as that’s also something doable that can help make those norms a reality.
However the real issue with your framing is, even if it is true, nobody will really take it seriously. It’s in the same kind of framing as “Taxes are Theft”. Like sure, from a certain point of view. However it really strips all nuance, and makes people recoil instinctively. Not saying you’re wrong, I just believe you can package it better.
Man get lost with this capitalist realism shit.
And I literally explained the nuance in my comment in plain language. I’m not here to spout paragraphs of political theory. If you want the long winded explanation go read Kropotkin.
wow, many “all billionaires are bad” comments…
and while true, this sounds like “two sides” argument. I haven’t heard of Gabe donating to pedophiles to keep his status as others have done, so maybe if Americans get their shit together and AOC/Bernie or the likes get the power and create a proper tax system, he won’t be among the ones that try very hard to dodge it.
Not sure what the argument is here, should he donate his money as a purity test? I’m ok with him just not interfering in politics and let people’s vote without interference try to create a more fair society. Also a very healthy individual being nice seems to be news nowadays, which is sad in itself, I would argue this should be the baseline, they already screw society by hoarding money, they shouldn’t be assholes on top of that.
The problem with America is that everyone wants equality until it touches a single dollar they own, then is to each their own/don’t touch my stuff, until that changes there is no point on doing simplistic “no billionaire” statements. Note how its no longer “no millionaires” because many people see a million achievable, so the only way of the request never being directed to oneself is increasing the amount to something unachievable. Individuality maxing.
And again, not defending billionaires, but adding some nuance to the conversation, this is not fixed by hard wall at 1B, it needs to be bracketed, otherwise it would be trivial to dodge (and unfair).
(writing this from a VERY socialist European country)
In the US, Billionaires are bad because their billions don’t come from taxable wages. They’re “ACAB”, because even if they personally aren’t human trash they still profit from the system built on the rules made to allow them to become billionaires.
They all profit from things like wage suppression, layoffs to extract more work from fewer people, replacement of employees with AI, freezing benefits or raising costs to things like medical, suppressing minimum wage, enshittification, etc.
No billionaire gets a billion because they worked for it and got a paycheck. They got it because your health care costs went up and you didn’t get a raise.
Never said billionaires were good, I just said that there is more nuance to it and that the problem with US is way deeper than that. The deeper problem is cultural, originating in “the American dream”, individuality and selfishness. All those problems you mention are true for billionaires, but are also true for multi millionaires, and I’d argue are true to a lower extent to the “normal Americans” who can’t stand their taxes going to help a poor family have healthcare because they think “they are taking mu money”. Obviously to different volumes and definitely the billionaires are at the top because of sheer money amount. But if you just draw an imaginary line at B because you think is prove enough, your argument is very weak, because a poorer person would draw that line somewhere else where you are uncomfortable. As I defended, the problem is sistemic and the solution must be implemented in all the levels. A bracketed taxing would tax higher to higher rents anyway, it just doesn’t say “all or nothing” at a random place, it increases steadily.
I don’t think they are drawing a line at a billion, I think that billionaire is being used as shorthand for “wealthy to the point that it is a detriment to society”.
It’s just that billionaire is shorter to type and it is a number so high that it’s undeniably detrimental, but a growing number of people have actually hit that number anyhow.
They’re “all cops are bastards”? I don’t understand.
All billionaires are bastards like all cops are bastards. There may be good ones, but they all still support the bad ones by making sure the system benefits them all and protects them.
I’m tired of living in a world where we’re relieved when extremely rich people treat others with respect.
Treating people with respect isn’t supposed to be noteworthy.
I like Gabe in the sense that he seems pretty decent, I like how he has structured his company.
However there should still be a wealth cap, and Billionaires shouldn’t exist on principle. They have an outsized portion of political power generated solely from their wealth, and that’s an issue. So Gabe still needs to stop being a Billionaire either by voluntary release or by force from mob or government.