The future is now old man
I was the old person for the longest time but then I learned how ridiculously insecure the clipboard system in x11 is and I was suddenly like “oh would you look at the time, it’s wayland o’ clock already”
Could you elaborate, please?
What features do you use? I was able to replicate just about everything I do with ydotool
Thanks to this wayland debacle, I accepted that as an X11 user I’m now retro. So I totally embraced this attitude. I don’t care about how awesome Wayland will one day be. I’m happy with all my old scripts running trustworthy xdotool and wmctrl.
Once I allowed myself this paradigm shift, I became happy. I’ve attained digital Ataraxia.
This is fine, however I don’t understand hard dependency on systemd. I wonder what will Void devs do about this.
KDE Plasma works fine with elogind.
Though, the systemd project could decide one day that logind requires the rest of systemd and make it more difficult to disentangle/extract elogind. They've said explicitly that nothing is stopping them from doing exactly that with udev, other than they just haven't yet.
Sure. That would be the moment I’d support a hard fork, because the system init part of systemd is not getting direct access to my hardware.
It’s not flickering and glitching enough to be a worthy representation of Wayland…
Also why all the knives? Every composer has to constantly invent the wheel (or in this case the hand-to-hand weapon) anew and implement their very own solution now. So I would expect more variety.
It’s not flickering and glitching enough to be a worthy representation of Wayland…
?
Wayland has artifacts everywhere all the damn time. (by which I mean way more often than X11 but it is better than it was and continues to improve)
🤷 I’ve never noticed that and I’ve been on Sway for quite a while now.
My main issue with Wayland is that the standard screen capture protocol for Wayland still isn’t widely supported.
I’ve moved to wayland… it is utter trash compared to X11 at actually doing its primary function. It is better at some fancyness that I don’t generally need though. Hopefully it will continue to improve… way better than a year ago.
I agree. Window snapping is basic functionality, yet Wayland doesn’t even have proper mechanisms to safely let applications do that. Wayland may be more secure, but it doesn’t feel usable, and its mediocre responsiveness decreases my productivity.
The Linux ecosystem is constantly fighting to get developers to build for its platform, yet it adapts functionality that prevents developers from implementing basic functions.
I don’t understand. I use KDE Wayland, and window snapping works fine? So to tiling scripts that “auto snap” windows.
It’s not that wayland is bad, but their DE’s or WM’s implementation is probably trash. KDE works beautifully. And I believe Gnome as well.
Like what? Whats the fanciness you don’t need, and what doesn’t function?
networking, windows that can position themselves (modals), global input events
Reading the Wikipedia definition, aren’t modals just sub-windows? I get those in KDE, but perhaps I misunderstand.
Per-application shortcuts feels like a feature to me, especially as I’ve had close brushes with keylogger malware.
I admit I never used the X11 networking stuff.
Actual graphics aren’t nearly as reliable (tested across 4 different AMD GPU’s released in the last I dunno 5 years) basic functionality is good enough to use but not good enough to give to a user to use it looks like a hollywood hacker film with the artifacts from time to time I would get calls. It is generally unpolished and still rough.
I can miracast screen over wifi way easier with Wayland. Yes this doesn’t only involve wayland.
Two easiest examples but the list of small grievances is large. Still it is moving in the right direction and new users will probably not know any difference of the mixed bag. And yes the security improvements which again great but can be a pita when you want to violate them. Bias towards the devil I know and what not. It has gotten good enough now that I use it without breaking my workflow as it did a few years ago. It is newer hasn’t gotten 40 years of polishing the rough edges.
I dunno. From a AMD 7950, to a Nvidia 980 TI, to a 2060 and my 3090 now, I could never get X acceptable for gaming or graphics stuff. Even browser scrolling felt like it was dropping or stuttering all the time.
…I just had to use Windows for most things, even though I didn’t want to and kept trying.
Wayland straight up didn’t work for a while, but when it did, holy moly. It was like night and day, immediately. No hitching, no artifacts, it just works.
So YMMV, clearly.
That’s the thing with linux: we are on different distros, making different configs, probably on different DEs, so our experience is going to be wildly different I guess. Not to speak of different applications and perceptions.
Curious to see if this project gains any momentum. xlibre.net
IIRC that’s some faschware
As a person who doesn’t really give a shit. I’ve even forgotten that I’m on Wayland. Everything I need works and that’s all that matters to me. Y’all can keep your wars to yourselves
That’s awesome.
50% of what I use doesn’t work and I will respond to the Wayland knife with C4.
Could you give some actual examples of the things that don’t work? I hear people say this a lot, but then they basically refuse to answer what’s not working. There was definitely a lot of wailing pain when it first transitioned, but these days, at least on plasma for me, I haven’t found anything that doesn’t work anymore. other than of course perhaps just some vague abandoned software that wants to do something crazy with the display
Plasma does solve some problems itself but: screen recording, global hotkeys, clipboard management to name a few. They all have “solutions”, it just sucks to be made to jump through hoops sometimes. There’s a lot of desirable things in x11 that while crusty worked well, like xrandr and being able to script monitor config. It is niche! But if you used it, it’s annoying to be forced off it
Here is a (biased but decent enough) list gist.github.com/…/9feb7c20257af5dd915e3a9f2d1f227…
Running on older nVidia cards causes visual glitches and memory leaks to the point where not even short remote sessions are usable. I have a Quadro K420 in my home server.
Replaced KDE with xfce and everything works perfectly again. Too bad they are forcing Wayland now.
I’m not an obstructionist but having been forced in to Wayland by plasma 6.8 it is frustrating that orcaslicer just crashes unless I tell it to run in xwayland and desk flow requires being on unstable to work with my clipboard and discord canary just shares audio from my whole desktop instead of from just my game and AGHHH I just want my things to work! So frustrating
Both orcaslicer and discord audio sharing work properly for me on Wayland. Are you sure Wayland is the issue?
I’ve had a bunch of issues with Orcaslicer and Wayland. Thankfully it’s currently working for me but the last year or so I kept having to switch back to X a lot for it.
The only variable I changed in testing was switching between the x11 and Wayland versions of plasma while I still could. Discord no longer prompts to provide an audio source, desktop will but the screen share won’t work once I actually start it. Orca crashes the moment I hit slice unless I add an environment variable to make it use x11 compatibility mode.
I don’t even know what I’m using. Whatever is default on Mint. It just works, I don’t want to think about my tools, I just want them to work. And, Mint does, for me.
I’ve even forgotten that I’m on Wayland. Everything I need works
different people have different needs and wants. Some people need X11, and want KDE or Gnome
Same as you, but I’m on X11
More power to you, friend. I honestly will never understand all the wars and politics in software, but it is what it is I guess.
Yeah, no need to make a religion out of sofware. With the exception of our lord and savior Emacs
im newbie to linux, and im using linux mint xfce, and i dont understand the meme hehe
Me too brother, me too. The command line is scary, but powerful, only if you know the correct incantations. You look those up in the tome labeled “Google”
i only use sudo apt update && sudo apt upgrade, and reboot lol, even when i turn off my laptop i use the mouse
This is completely fine. No need to use the terminal if you feel more comfortable using the mouse. I would only recommend to substitute upgrade for full-upgrade in your command. This really installs all available updates even if it requires to install new dependencies.
Give the fish shell a try if you’re intimidated by bash
I’ve been using Linux for ~17 years and Xfce is my goto interface. You’re in good hands.
X11 still works better for me. I also can’t stand how my windows just pop all up in the middle of my screen on a single virtual desktop. On x11 they remebered their place. I also had better gaming performance with Manjaro + x11 instead of catchyos + wayland.
Tiling window managers!
I don’t disagree but this should not be the only solution for “remember where I put you last”
x11 + Manjaro frame delivery was so bad I literally had to use Windows for gaming to not get sick. And I really tried…
Ya I can’t explain it. My Manjaro was running so good. I switched after the drama with the Manjaro team, figuring a gaming dedicated OS would be better. I play the same game sometimes side by side with a user on a steam deck and I get more random frame drops. Kinda wild. But this also runs nvidia so…
I mean, this was some time ago; you shouldn’t be running X11 on Nvidia if you want to game these days.
It’s little things for me, like how the first keystroke on the lock screen is part of my password entry with X11, but not with Wayland. Subtle changes in new window and focus behavior. I do still want a persistent bar, with a window list, tray, clock, and menu, but I think I’m going to switch to something like Ratpoison or i3; something tiling with good keyboard control.
Don’t think that’s wayland. I’m using kde plasma and wayland, and first keystroke is definitely part of the lock screen password.
I have 2 fedora plasma instances and both of them miss the first character when I enter the password on the lock screen. It’s very annoying
I dualboot i3 debian (x11) and gentoo with -X useflag. I don’t know why yet but nonethless.
Wayland is so smooth. When I go to my friends house and use mint I’m instantly reminded how shit x11. Screentearing on the desktop, cmon what year is this.
I thought Cinnamon finally added Wayland support now? Anyway I had the same experience. Using Mint is how I realized 90% of distro recommenders on reddit and Lemmy have 0 fucking clue what they’re talking about
They added experimental support and i think they made it mostly functional in the upcoming release but dont quote me on that last bit
If you're getting screen tearing, it's not X11's fault. It's the graphics manufacturers putting speed over stability.
I had an old Nvidia card that I never had a problem with under X11. The moment I upgraded to an AMD card, screen tearing, screen tearing everywhere.
To fix, you generally need to slap a small config file into /etc/X11/xorg.conf.d that tells the graphics driver that slow and steady wins the race.
The AMD solution literally contains the line Option "TearFree" "true". Ridiculous.
Link to one of many sites providing the full solutions: https://linuxjunkies.org/guides/fix-screen-tearing-on-linux
If you’re getting screen tearing, it’s not X11’s fault. It’s the graphics manufacturers putting speed over stability.
This is the central part of why wayland adoption has been difficult. With X11, the idea is “the buck stops here”, with wayland it’s “this is out of scope.”
Now, in terms of managing a cleaner project, which is wayland’s goal, that’s fair.
However, in the practicalities of seamless adoption and not breaking shit, it’s not being the “drop in replacement and new standard” it’s hoping to be.
What is the origin of this meme? Why do they want to kill this poor man who presumably lives there and just mowed the lawn?
Apparently the original:
The edit looks less edited than the original.
Right? Knives look more natural than clothes unmoving from a package, wayyyy to much cornstarch if the shirts are holding that well.
If you squint, it looks like Wayland is stabbing itself lol.
Also literally just waiting for wayfire and XFCE to become stable and I’ll switch off from Compiz.
Biggest issue with Wayland is/was the lack of feature parity with X11 and the painfully slow development time (I still argue Wayland only became viable start of 2025 after a bunch of major PR merges).
Ngl I have no clue which one I use. I was experimenting with them a year ago but I cannkt say which one I settled on.
Aaaaand… GNOME still haven’t implemented server-side decorations.
Now that it at least supports my multiscreen, multi UI scale setup, it feels like Wayland is what all DE’s want to be. It’s so smooth and fast, and can always impose it’s will on all the windows. What do you mean this window won’t minimize and always stays on top?? WAYLAND SMASH. There I fixed it.
It feels very luxurious and decadent to have a DE that is so frocking good and reliable.
Is there a single, unified product that I can use for remote desktop access to Linux running either X11 or Wayland, Windows, and MacOS? I provide support for family that are both Windows and Mac users (and one Linux user, yay!). I’d like a single remote desktop solution for everything that is easy to get Windows users and MacOS users to install. I’ve been using AnyDesk, because ninite.com has an installer for it, so it’s a low bar for low-skilled windows users, and it’s easy enought to get installed on MacOS. But incoming Anydesk connections don’t work on Wayland. Does Rustdesk handle incoming Wayland connections these days?
Just try it. Rustdesk works really well, but I haven’t tried it on Wayland. If you already have a wayland machine, it won’t do harm to try.
I have tried it in the past. It was great but I could only connect to running wayland sessions. It wouldn’t handle the login screen. Also the public server performance was pretty spotty, but I could always self-host the server.
I know how LongtimeUser4 feels. His use case is ludicrous, sure, but xkcd's ideas don't come out of nothing.
I am dreading trying to rewrite my scripts that currently rely on
xdotoolandwmctrl. When last I looked into it, the equivalents didn't cover the features I use, and the rationale from Wayland seems to be "why would you want to do that, old man?"Workflow