I realised recently that it's actually preferable to not be technically correct when being technically correct can make the side of a just cause cede ground to fuckheads
@chrisjrn In terms of accountability, it still needs to land on the heads of those fuckheads though I think? If they come around in time and go "Oh, it's AI's fault," that shouldn't get them off the hook - if "AI" goes away tomorrow, those same people will continue making shitty management decisions that affect the livelihood and wellbeing of others (maybe with less power, but a systemic problem remains)
@chrisjrn Absolutely do hope that "AI" goes away tomorrow, of course and that the companies peddling LLM-as-a-service garbage are held accountable for the harm they've participated in when it comes to climate, economies, mental health, culture, etc.
@chrisjrn I mean, there's no such thing as a singular root cause in complex systems. There are only contributing factors, and it's weird how many people are working so hard to downplay the contribution of AI in recent computing disruptions
@chrisjrn It's not even incorrect to say that AI was a factor. AI definitely, directly contributed to the planning of the changes that precipitated both the MS and FAA outages. AI definitely, directly lead people to operate at a greater remove from the physical reality of the systems. AI definitely soaked up an enormous amount of investment that would otherwise have been available. AI definitely contributed to setting and justifying executive expectations and staffing decisions.
It's preposterous to pretend otherwise, or that these factors were irrelevant
@jenniferplusplus and this is why it's such a silly idea to cede that argument in the first place!
@chrisjrn I saw someone compare to climate change.
Did this specific hurricane happen because of human caused climate change? Impossible to say.
Did human caused climate change make it more likely and more intense? Almost certainly.
Does the difference matter when talking about the impact of human caused climate change? Probably not.
example: AI probably did not technically cause the multi-day Outlook Cloud outage; it was probably because experienced people were laid off on the pretense of AI making their jobs unnecessary
is the difference between AI itself and the concept of AI actually a useful rhetorical distinction here?