Reddit is changing the feed apparently (image from post)
They were on lisp right? At some point? I forget when they did the first “redesign”. You could see everything before that. up/down votes. There were even metadata sites that helped so you could see when a bandwagon happened.
They started with Lisp, and eventually did a rewrite in python for performance reasons. There was even an open source version for a bit, not there’s a point to that anymore. Y Combinator and Paul Graham might’ve been mentioned in those days.
Once again everyone forgets the_donald. Right wing trolls figured out how to game the reddit feed so they can control exactly what posts are in what specific order /r/all.
Does no one remember when they used to make it show Trump’s face across multiple post thumbnails?
That’s why it had to be nerfed. Whatever determines the feed isn’t organic user activity because trolls will manipulate it. The feeds people see most definitely curated in some way. It’s been this way since just after 2016.
When the epstein files dropped they did weird shit with anime porn. r/all was a battlefield of bots pushing that gross shit covering up the legitimate posts that were actually leading to relevant good discussions too.
That’s why I kept on looking at reddit for a long time. It’s not about the content you see. There tends to be some meta going on. People look at it to laugh at the memes, thinking it’s random silliness. There’s more to it than meets the eye.
It sounds like, based on what youre describing, that the users figured out how to game the algorithm, but the moderation tools at the time were not up to the task of identifying the abusive behavior. So, rather than address the problem, they altered their algorithm to cover over it, which created a new problem intrinsic to the system that made the decisions on what a user sees into a mystery.
I know what youre talking about posts started sticking around longer and the upvote count became inflated cuz posts would stick around way longer. You’d start seeing 3k upvotes on a post that was an hour old and users started spamming trash cuz even that would last long enough to be upvoted into olbivion
I remember this too, can’t find good articles either but my recollection is that it was partly due to the Boston bomber incident. Wanting to slow down how fast things reached the front page before they could be moderated.
I do remember how it used to change every few seconds, and how it’s definitely slowed down with time.
The Safereddit front end is working for me right now, if anyone wants to see the discussion:
“Reddit is refusing requests. Showing page from 12 minutes ago.”
We can’t have nice things
It’s hit or miss for me with Reddit front ends to start with; I guess we’re lucky it was up that long. Sorry about that.
I’m still a bit amazed they got rid of r/all.
(Yes I know old reddit still exists. I don’t know how anyone uses that site without it or third party whatsits)
Kinda want to thank them for being awful enough to push me to try something else, like Microsoft.
It feels like 70% of the content is video now. Like it’s trying to be endless scroll tiktok videos.
its either that or memes, or politics, or the fake stories posts like AITA, girl and boy dinner diaries. like every 3rd post is one of those aita /diaries posts, and it seems you cant call out the story for being AI generated or bot posted anymore.
The dinner diary shit is so low effort it kills me. Here’s a picture of a my sad lasagna, my SO doesn’t love me.
Yes I know old reddit still exists.
For now, they are currently bleeding it dry (the userbase is locked down, it's not possible to become a new old reddit user anymore). It's basically just rotting in a cell waiting for its death sentence at this point.
If you browse old Reddit and click on a picture or video served by Reddit themselves it takes you to the same topic but on new Reddit. I wonder how many people, once on new, dont3go back to old.
Wait so what does subscribing to a sub mean now? Sucks that Reddit is so important in niche hobbies but terrible in every other way.
I have quoted that line for about 25 years now.
Nice to see a few Piefed and Lemmy mentions there.
I welcome any new users with open arms! Reddit’s been on a constant downward slope since I left, and still shows no signs of stopping. It’s slower but hopefully people recognize there’s no profit motive for engagement so the comments and posts that are here generally are higher quality.
Lemmy mods are just as censorious as those on Reddit. And both hide their censorship shenanigans from other users.
Yeah so many posts asking what alternatives there are to reddit and I’m like come on damn. The Fediverse needs better marketing.
So far, RedReader has worked well for me for occasional browsing/looking stuff up there. I think I got it through fdroid.
Oh damn thanks for this. I wonder if the no login access will break apps like this for good?
I feels like it has such a small user base (less that 0.1% of users) that they have kind of forgotten that it still has API access.
But start of next year a lot of apps on F-Droid will go dark when the next “security” measures come into place and apps become unverified.
I wonder if the Redditors will ever get mad enough to leave. One can hope.
Redditors leave every day.
The better question is whether more people are entering the system.
Pretty much. It wont’ be like the Digg exodus that made Reddit what it was, it is a slow bleed until it become a bot power waste land.
That’s not bad luck, that’s sheer fucking idiocy
So annoying seeing old news
that’ll teach you.
I just came back here and created a new account yesterday because they’ve made changes that make it blatantly obvious they are going the way of Meta and Google.
There are now two tabs on the main page:
- “For You” is a new experience set as the default which is basically like the main YouTube feed where it’s just serving up stuff they think you would like instead of honoring your subscriptions.
- “Following” is the other tab which only shows you’re subscribed to. If you switch to this tab, it does honor that choice and come back to that tab the next time you open your feed in the same browser.
I also saw the “Top” option disappear from my dropdown on mobile for like a week. It’s back now, so it could have been a browser glitch or something since I clear my cookies never, but seeing my only method for sorting that didn’t put posts with like 4 upvotes in front of me constantly disappear was enough to make me say “fuck this”.
It’s clear they want eyes on the platform and are manipulating things the same way every other social media company has to provide a new enshittified experience that makes them more money with zero regard to what brought them their user base. Yet another company forgetting where they came from to try and milk the cash cow while their original users flee to other platforms.
I still went on Reddit for a while after the API nonsense because it was still mainly a forum working on a vote-based system. Sure, it was going to be manipulated and marketers and dipshits were going to play the system, but it was at least set up in a way that ostensibly put people in control of the content they saw. Now that they’re moving away from that, I’d rather just post more content here to make this site more useful than try to figure out which buttons to push to make that site useful.
Now, I just use Mastodon for my InfoSec news and snark and come here for conversations that don’t feel manipulated or performative. I know that exists here, but people have actual unique opinions and hate advertising and corporate control as a rule.
serving up stuff they think you would like
I know this is already your point, but you should rephrase things as “Serving stuff to keep you on the platform” or “See more ads”. They don’t care, at all, if you are enjoying your time on the app. They just want you on it for as long as possible, even better, seeing as many ads as possible.
They don’t care, at all, if you are enjoying your time on the app.
I mean, the goal is to make it addictive. Are addicts having a good time?
Great point. They don’t care if I love it, hate it, or am annoyed by it. If I’m still there looking and/or engaging with it, they’re happy.
In fact, they’re aware that it’s best if it makes you mad, but only mad enough to interact, not to leave.
Using an ad blocker to bypass the login popup now results in only 3 posts loading at a time
Not posting there anymore, but still haven’t gotten around to removing my content.
Does someone know a good way to backup everything (so that it can be traced back to its context - for my own reference) and then mass edit my posts and comments?
I’ve been thinking about the same. I’m afraid most of the major LLMs have been trained on it already, regardless.
Yeah, no question about that, I just want to prevent any further usage.
You can request your data, which will give you a bunch of zips after a slight wait. Not sure how much ctx is in there since I haven’t opened them up since the day I got them.
It’s funny after 13 years I felt so attached to my part in that place, and then suddenly one day I wasn’t. I don’t know where my backups are now and I don’t care.
I used “power delete suite” to mass edit my comments into random observations. What’s funny is before I deleted my account I would get comments like “wtf does John Wick have to do with deontology?” Haha.
I feel a bit bad because it was a useful repository of genuine interactions, and some people still cling to that old dream. But the place is not made for people. Not anymore anyway.
Looked up Power Delete Suite, it says it can save besides editing/deleting. I think I’ve seen it before, but thought maybe it’s not the right tool because it was made before the API drama of about 3 years ago (which seems to have driven many people out). I’ll give it a try, thanks.
At least I haven’t seen that ditzy etsy ad since I mocked it lol!
They already ban anyone who expresses wrongthink, shadowban posts that they don’t want to be seen, and push the most popular comments to the top while hiding the least popular at the bottom. It’s the most heavily censored and manipulated forum on the internet, and it’s still not good enough. The reddit mods need even more control.
For the love of Christ I hope redditors just leave the goddamn platform already. Go anywhere else.
Oh it is so much worse here in Australia.
I just went to check something on there, was greeted by the login just to read it, was then immediately flagged as “Your account is restricted to minors” it then requested government ID or a selfie to confirm my age.
So yeah, I haven’t posted for years but now I just wont visit. Nice job Reddit, you done goofed yourself like Digg did.

I can’t even find them anymore, but I swear there were articles sometime around 2015-2016ish commenting on a slowdown of the feeds. I noticed it, too. In the early days of Reddit there was so much content every time you refreshed the page, but then they fucked with the algorithm hard and posts lingered much longer. It’s been a long, slow decline and we’re at the point where the wheels are full coming off, but it’s been coming awhile no doubt.
EDIT: I half-heartedly tried to research this a bit but it’s really hard to surface articles I don’t remember many details on from near a decade ago with the internet in the state that it’s in. Looks like maybe around ~2018 they changed how Best/Hot was calculated and this resulted in slowing of new content onto feeds, I think that’s what I’m remembering …