my favorite bible story is Daniel-in-the-Lions'-den. okay before i lose a bunch of followers over this, the reasons im about to discuss have nothing to do with religious evangelism and everything to do with it having some actual human drama amongst the didactic messaging
we have Daniel, living as a compulsory expat in Babylon and he's actually kicking ass. The king, Darius, loves this guy. Now we've all heard this part in Sunday school, the king's other advisors get jealous so they have the king make a law that everyone has to worship the king and Daniel is nah, and they throw him to the lions, but then God makes the lions nice. Wow. But let's back up because the Sunday school version completely fucks up what's actually interesting about this story
So as established, we have Daniel, ace bureaucrat (foreigner) and we have King Darius (foreigner)... Wait what? Yeah Sunday school didn't mention that detail now did they? Darius was a Persian king, Babylon got its own ass conquered. And we have the other bureaucrats (not foreigners) ... u already see there's some tension here!
Darius was called a king but he was actually a colonial governor they just called a king because they hadn't invented colonialism yet. his job was to make sure tribute kept flowing from Babylon to Persia, where his boss, the King-of-Kings was. He was installed as the governor of Babylon after it was conquered. All the existing bureaucrats kept their jobs, they just got a new boss to call "your majesty"
Darius loves Daniel because Daniel is smart and competent and also totally trustworthy because he isn't loyal to the now-conquered Babylonian aristocracy (who, u kno, enslaved him). So Darius makes Daniel in charge of all the Babylonian bureaucrats. They're pissed off: they got conquered and the foreign king makes a foreign guy they used to kick around THEIR boss? some guy from some other ethnic group (other ethnic groups are obviously inferior!!!!)
They can't get rid of the king (regicide is risky business) but they sure as fucjk can try to get rid of that foreign jew. The Babylonian bureaucrats go "okay this guy is a career bureaucrat there has GOT to be some dirt on this guy". They go over his life with a fine toothed comb looking for evidence of incompetence or corruption. There's gotta at least be some bribe taking? Embezzlement? No? FUCK
So the Babylonian bureaucrats are like, okay, well Daniel is a fuckin foreigner how do we make that illegal? Obvs can't make all foreigners illegal, the king (foreigner) would never go for it. Okay so how is Daniel's foreign-ness different from Darius's foreign-ness? ....the fucker's monotheistic! JACKPOT
In Sunday school they mention the advisors convince the king to make a law ordering everyone to worship him as a god which makes him seem totally unhinged (wrong Daniel-wrangled king, it was the earlier Nebuchadnezzar II that was unhinged!) which completely flattens out how insidious the manipulation was. u see back then, polytheism was the norm and basically all kings claimed to be gods, it was the same as euro-kings claiming to have been installed by God 2k years later.
When a king said he was a god people were like oh okay whatever, did the 550 BCE equivalent of saying "god save the king" and went on with their lives. They already worship like 20 other gods, what's one more?
So Darius was like oh so for 30 days everyone prays just to me? And the Babylonian bureaucrats are like yeah every time there's a new king we do that it's SOP.
Darius is like and this will make me seem more legit? cuz that's how y'all do things here, right? okay ill sign
As soon as Darius figured out he actually signed a "No Daniels allowed" law, he wanted to take it back. Something glossed over in Sunday school is that Darius was the equivalent of a constitutional monarch, he couldn't just do whatever he wanted (it was that other Daniel-wrangled king that went all "l'etat c'est moi") Of course in practice even a constitutional monarch is not actually bound by law unless he pisses off the elites. It's a broken tail light thing. Well so about those elites...
Darius is like whoa hey, i didn't know that Daniel was one of those "monotheists", im new here! hey we don't even have telegraph lines or whatever yet who even knows about the law lets just take it back, And this is the real interesting part Sunday school never mentions. The Babylonian aristos come to Darius in a big group and are like... nice legitimacy you have there. Sure would be a shame if something happened to it....
The Babylonian aristos had the self-proclaimed god-king by the balls
Daniel knows about the law but he goes to pray as usual. In his own house. But the Babylonian bureaucrats SWAT him immediately and catch him in the act. And Daniel expected them to. But he wasn't gonna pray to his nice but slightly dim-witted boss even on pain of death. Look he didn't pray to Babylonian Louis XIV, he sure as fuck isn't gonna pray to Persian "why can't i hold all these limes?" guy
Darius, ace colonial governor/god-king, is freaking out, checking the law, looking for any loophole he can use to take back the edict without causing the Babylonian aristocracy to revolt (which would get him in deep shit. if the tribute stops flowing, the Babylonian bureaucrats don't even have to string him up, the Persian king-of-kings will do it for them). He can't find anything so he huddles in bed fasting all night (probably too nauseous to keep down red wine and chocolate ice cream)
Not sure the Babylonians had Ice Cream (Persians had ice I think ?) but I'm quite certain they didn't have chocolate.
So I'm quite grossed out at what would pass for chocolote cream at the time...
Right, so : do we have any account of how the peasants staying in Judah lived ?
Did they keep observance ? Did their religion diverge from the Babylonian elites ?
Did they have some sort of contact with the Babylonian elite ?
@lienrag OMG this is unironically one of my favorite topics and deserves its own thread.
Oh boy cuz eventually the elites in Babylon did get sent back after having been gone a few generations and there was a HUGE conflict over who the "real" Judeans were
@Xibanya I did not expect to start my morning with some neat historical-critical method analysis of the old testament but here we are, this is so neat
@gabrielesvelto thanks for reading my biblical rambles!
@Xibanya you know my wife's a minister so I occasionally volunteer to do Sunday school, and while we usually have some really good material to prepare your thread is definitely gonna see some use in the future
@gabrielesvelto 😁 that makes me so happy to hear
@Xibanya oh shit this sounds fun *grabs some popcorn*
the story takes place in Babylon, which, the sharp reader may notice, is not Israel. That's because the kingdom of judah got conquered and the Babylonians took the elites back with them as slaves and left the peasants (peasants being interchangeable and ya gotta have somebody tillin them fields you kno?)