@hardpenguin13 Regarding automation, I recall a talk or article by Mike Bostock about makefiles ages ago, and the part that's stuck with me is how one of the most powerful lenses to view automation scripts through is to see them as machine readable *documentation*.
The rationales for why "AI" really shouldn't be generating docs/taking minutes/doing anything else that describes intent also apply to automation too IMO
@Cheeseness I like that point but automation is sometimes much simpler than that.
I automate things like clicks and mouse movements or text copy and pastes on my computer. I can script that fast enough by myself luckily but I guess I could see someone wanting to use simple AI for that.
I still think it's better to learn what you're doing though instead of being a so called automation monkey
@hardpenguin13 What you describe is what I'm talking about. Automating those things documents processes/workflows.
I often find that if I return to some task I haven't done in a long time that reading my scripts gets me back up to speed pretty much instantly.
@Cheeseness @hardpenguin13 yeah, I think about the only times I feel comfortable with vibe-coded software (once the externalities are resolved, if even possible) is when the user has effectively documented what the thing will do down to how it will do it, ideally because they wrote every single comment.
When the AI writes comments? That's where madness lies.
Please boost the poll itself!
My take: I absolutely HATE what we've done to machine learning. We as in the capitalist society. I don't want to use any corporate-backed non-open source "AI" tool. Or anything that was trained on stolen data, used without specific & not forced permission.
But I do think ML has incredible accessibility uses (speech recognition to text, image recognition).
Maaaaaybe some automation too. Super reluctant about that part. Because what's wrong with manual scripting?